Go to content
Hidden Tuscany
Casetta di Valentina — Castiglione della Pescaia
Restaurant

Casetta di Valentina

Italian cuisine Via del Poggetto, 58043, Castiglione Della Pescaia, Castiglione della Pescaia€€ · Mid-range 32 reviews in the last 30 days
8,2/10

Hidden Tuscany Rating

Very good

La carte est dominée par la Maremme : pici, tortello maremmano, cinghiale, Morellino, pecorino et chianina, avec pâtes fraîches et producteurs nommés. Réserve : le prix moyen de 30 € reste cohérent, mais la braise facturée à l’hecto peut alourdir l’addition.

Note des voyageurs 9,2/10 · 264 avis

  • Cuisine30 %8,3

    Note voyageurs 9,3/10 sur 264 avis : dans les 27 % les mieux classés du catalogue.

  • Service15 %7,3

    Note voyageurs 9,0/10 sur 264 avis : dans les 49 % les mieux classés du catalogue.

  • Setting15 %8,5

    Note voyageurs 9,3/10 sur 264 avis : dans les 22 % les mieux classés du catalogue.

  • Value for money20 %7,6

    Prix moyen de 30 € pour des plats à 15-20 €, pâtes fraîches et produits nommés : c’est cohérent, mais la braise à l’hecto peut faire monter l’addition.

  • Local typicality20 %9,1

    Typicité marquée : pici, tortello maremmano, cinghiale, Morellino, pecorino, chianina et producteurs nommés ; quelques plats génériques restent marginaux.

Évaluée le 20 October 2026 · fiabilité des informations : high

Independent rating, calculated from the property's public information and traveler reviews. Commissions received on bookings are not included in the rating.

Comment on note

Our opinion

Cuisine9,3
Service9,0
Atmosphere9,3

Casetta di Valentina: authentic Maremma, no frills

If you're looking for the real Tuscany, the one that doesn't put on makeup for tourists, then listen to me carefully. In Castiglione della Pescaia, Casetta di Valentina is not just another address, it's an agriturismo offering homemade cuisine, with local products, far from tourist traps.

The Maremma on your plate, no frills

Here, they don't sell you a dream, they serve you the real thing. The house is renowned for its "typical Maremma" cuisine, and that's a promise kept. We're talking about fresh pasta made on the spot: tortelli, pici, tagliatelle. You'll also find the Flan di verdure di stagione con fonduta e cialda di pecorino, a Selezione di salumi di nostra produzione, and even a Paté di fegato served with brioche bread and caramelized onion. These are dishes that speak of the land, not the inventions of a starred chef.

The setting? Forget the stiff restaurants downtown. Here, you're in the countryside, among olive trees, a few kilometers from the sea. It's simple, family-friendly, rustic. They talk about a family-run atmosphere, an agriturismo with a pool, a green environment. It's the kind of place where you feel at home, no fuss, just the pleasure of feeling good and eating well.

Why this restaurant over another?

Because Casetta di Valentina guarantees a cuisine that doesn't cheat, rooted in its terroir. Customers say it: the quality is there, the service is attentive, and all for a reasonable price, around €30 per person. If you want to taste the Maremma without getting ripped off, this is an address to remember.

Location

Where to stay nearby, live prices

Is the map not displaying? See accommodations on Stay22

Map and prices provided by Stay22: Toscane Cachée may receive a commission on bookings.

Nearby

Restaurant
Castiglione della Pescaia · < 1 km

Gitano.me

6,3Fair≈ 36 € / pers.
Restaurant
Castiglione della Pescaia · < 1 km

Da Ammore

6,5Fair≈ 20 € / pers.
Restaurant
Castiglione della Pescaia · < 1 km

So Good

5,8What we like less≈ 15 € / pers.
Restaurant
Castiglione della Pescaia · 1,1 km

La Bitta

6,5Fair≈ 25 € / pers.
Agriturismo
Castiglione della Pescaia · 1.2 km

Agriturist Prile

7,3Goodfrom 120 € / night
Apartment
Vetulonia · 5.3 km

Loc.Cioccaie

6,7Fairfrom 386 € / night

The menu

Per iniziare

  • Seasonal vegetable flan with fondue and a pecorino wafer €15
  • Selection of our own cured meats €17
  • Liver pâté served with brioche bread and caramelized onion €17
  • Degustazione di formaggi de l'azienda il fiorino €18
  • Tartare di selvaggina €19
  • Sweetbreads, agretti and balsamic sauce €19
  • Taste “la casetta” (min. 2 people) €49

Primi piatti

  • Pici with aglione sauce €16
  • Maremman tortello with classic ragù or butter and sage €16
  • Green gnocco with white wild boar ragù €17
  • Cappellaccio filled with pigeon with flakes of pecorino romano on onion cream cooked in morellino €19

Secondi piatti

  • Wild boar with apples €16
  • Braised veal cheek in morellino €18
  • Rabbit in porchetta style with potato stuffing €20

Dalla nostra brace

  • Tagliata (Terre di Sacra) - (hg) €10
  • Maremman Fiorentina (terre di sacra) - (hg) €8
  • Chianina Fiorentina (azienda mattone) - (hg) €9

Contorni

  • Contorni €5

Dolci

  • Yogurt cheesecake served with our fruit jam €6
  • Tiramisù €6
  • Torta di mele al rum €6
  • Deconstructed mille-feuille with chantilly cream and seasonal fruit €7
  • Whipped ricotta with cantucci crumble and vin santo reduction €7
  • Homemade cantucci and vin santo “montellori” €9

Bevande

  • Acqua €3
  • Caffè €2
  • Tuscan cola 33ml “le spume del papini” €4
  • Blonde beer 33ml “la stecciaia” €7

Avoid the showy terraces of the harbor and climb up among the olive trees instead: for the price of a beach snack, you get real homemade Maremma tortelli!

Tosco
Agriturismo Activities Sleep Eat Plan Car