Top 30: Agriturismos milieu de gamme en Maremme

Tosco The tiebreaker comes down to the pool and breakfast: Corte degli Ulivi offers a seasonal pool and rooms with kitchenettes, but breakfast costs €15 extra and dinner is not confirmed. Diaccia Botrona, on the other hand, bets on the table: handmade dinners by reservation, vegetables from the kitchen garden, and a traveler rating of 9.5/10 from 58 reviews. If you want swimming and a comfortable stay, go to Grosseto; if you prefer eating well and being a stone's throw from the sea, the Castiglione hill is the right pick.

Tosco Diaccia Botrona wins on the table and farm character: kitchen garden, orchard, homemade dinners, and a score of 8.0 versus 7.8. Choose it if you want a real farm a few minutes from the sea, as a couple or with friends. Le Cascatelle, on the other hand, suits you better if you want comfort (spa, high-end bedding, free parking) and can accept paying €10 extra for breakfast.

Tosco Corte degli Ulivi wins for those who want a true organic farm and a 19th-century manor house, with a Hidden Tuscany score of 8.0 versus 7.8 and authenticity criteria rated higher (8.4 versus 7.3). Le Cascatelle, at €124 versus €129, will appeal more to those looking for a spa, an on-site restaurant, and room to accommodate a group, with its comfort rated at 8.2. Both have the same traveler rating, 9.4/10.

Tosco Organic Agriturismo Corte degli Ulivi is the strongest on the Note Toscane Cachée (8.0 vs. 7.8) and on authenticity, with its 19th-century colonial house, vineyards and organic oil, at €129 a night versus €145 for Podere l'Aione. Choose it if you want an old setting and a gentler price, but budget €15 more if you take breakfast. Podere l'Aione, for its part, wins on the table (buffet breakfast included, homemade dinners) and on traveler reviews (9.8/10), so it's the better pick for a more indulgent stay.

Tosco Diaccia Botrona earns the Hidden Tuscany Score (8.0 versus 7.8) thanks to much stronger authenticity and a much stronger table, with handmade dinners and a home-produced olive oil and wine, for €120 a night. If you want a pool and breakfast included, Podere l'Aione in Scansano (€145) is the obvious choice, but you'll have to settle for sparsely detailed rooms and a less flattering traveler rating.

Tosco On the Cascatelle side, you gain the spa, high-end bedding, and free parking, with an 8.2 for comfort versus 7.8 for l'Aione, but its farm authenticity is weaker (7.3 versus 8.7). At l'Aione, you get a real 30-hectare farm, a pool, and free breakfast, for €145 versus €124 plus €10 for breakfast elsewhere. Both have an overall score of 7.8, so I'll settle it based on what you want: a couple who wants comfort and a spa, or lovers of local produce and a pool.