Top 30: Agriturismos avec vue sur les collines en Maremme

Tosco Cerchio Verde takes the lead with a score of 8.1 against 7.9, and above all a clearer authenticity: a working farm with olive groves and vines for DOC wines, at €244 a night versus €255 for Il Felciaione. If you're looking for true farm character and don't care about the spa, it's Cerchio Verde; if you want a pool and spa with the best traveler rating (9.8 against 9.4), it's Il Felciaione, in Massa Marittima and not Pitigliano.

Tosco Cerchio Verde stands out for its authenticity (8.6) and reviews at 9.4/10, but at €244 a night it targets those who want a restored farm in the upper range, with a pool and an on-site restaurant. Agriturismo La Dependance, at €95, offers a richer table (8.4) and reviews at 9.6/10 for a tight budget, in an independent family house, provided you check the rooms before booking.

Tosco Cerchio Verde clearly outperforms on the Hidden Tuscany Score (8.1 against 7.8) and on authenticity, with a real working farm, an olive grove and only 4 rooms, for €244 a night versus €384 at Fattoria Di Magliano Winery. Choose it if you want rural calm and a more reasonable budget. Fattoria Di Magliano Winery, for its part, suits those looking for a luxury wine estate with tastings and sporting activities, provided you accept a high price and comfort details that are still unclear.

Tosco Il Felciaione wins on the Hidden Tuscany Score (7.9 against 7.8) and on the authenticity of the setting, with a real farm estate and a wine produced on site, for €255 a night versus €384 at Fattoria Di Magliano Winery. Choose it if you want a pool, spa and restaurant without paying luxury prices, or if the rural atmosphere matters more than prestige. Fattoria Di Magliano Winery, with its higher traveler rating (9.2/10 from 428 reviews, against 9.8/10 from 126 for Il Felciaione), is better suited to someone looking for a working wine estate and an unapologetically luxurious budget.

Tosco The tie-break comes down to the Hidden Tuscany Score: 7.8 for Fattoria Di Magliano Winery against 7.7 for Agriresort La Colombaia, a minimal gap. The Fattoria, at €384, suits you if you want a working wine estate, with a winery, tastings and an authentic setting (8.3). La Colombaia, at €438 and with 9.5/10 from 35 reviews, appeals more if you value breakfast included and a 17th-century building renovated in 2020, with its olive groves.

Tosco Price comes first: La Dependance costs €95 a night against €255 for Il Felciaione, and its Hidden Tuscany Score of 8.0 places it ahead of the 7.9 of the Massa Marittima estate. If you're travelling as a couple on a small budget and want a true rural setting, with a pool, home-cooked dinner and estate wine, it's the one. If you're after a spa, an on-site restaurant and a more polished stay, Il Felciaione better meets that need, even if the score gap is slim.