Top 8: Agriturismos avec vue sur les collines à Montemerano

Tosco If you want a table d'hôte with a restaurant and estate wine for a dinner on site, choose Agriturismo Il Poggiolo, cheaper at €216 and better rated for value for money. If your pleasure comes first from other travelers' reviews and a precise rural setting, with eight rooms and a garden 1.8 km from Montemerano, Agriturismo La Vecchia Quercia will appeal to you, despite its €234 and less detailed services. The travelers' rating for the latter is excellent (9.3/10 from 162 reviews), but its listing remains vague about the pool and air conditioning; it's up to you whether you prefer precise amenities or the reputation of the hosts.

Tosco Price is the deciding factor here: Il Poggiolo costs €216 a night versus €158 for La Bell'antiglia, for a Toscane Cachée rating of 7.7 versus 7.5. Il Poggiolo suits those who want a 16th-century casale with house wine, an on-site restaurant and a pool, and who are willing to pay for that. La Bell'antiglia, with its 9.2/10 across 246 reviews, appeals to those looking for a characterful old podere at a lower price, with homemade breakfast.

Tosco Price settles it quickly: Il Poggiolo at €216 a night versus €309 for Il Poggio Di Teo, and Poggiolo's edge also comes from its setting (8.3, 16th-century casale, estate wine) and its table (7.8). If you want a spa and a centuries-old garden, Il Poggio Di Teo, with its Toscane Cachée score of 7.5 versus 7.7 and 163 traveler reviews at 9.2, remains a serious option.

Tosco The tiebreaker comes down to setting and comfort: La Vecchia Quercia wins on authenticity (8.7 versus 7.2) with vineyards, house wine and a restored farmhouse, while Il Poggio Di Teo takes the lead on amenities (7.4 versus 6.9) with a pool, spa and restaurant. Choose La Vecchia Quercia at €234 if you want a rural stay and estate wine; Il Poggio Di Teo at €309 if you're looking for a pool, spa and meals on site. Traveler ratings are nearly identical (9.3 versus 9.2).

Tosco On price, La Bell'antiglia takes the lead: €158 a night versus €234 for La Vecchia Quercia, with a pool (June to September), breakfast included and dinner on request. If you want character, house wine and a more distinctive setting, La Vecchia Quercia has the best authenticity score (8.7) and plenty to appeal to wine lovers, but you'll need to stretch the budget. For a small budget or a romantic getaway with a pool, La Bell'antiglia is the most sensible choice.

Tosco On price, La Bell'antiglia at €158 a night holds its own against Il Poggio Di Teo at €309, with a pool, breakfast and dinner on request in both cases. For a small budget or a couple who wants a true rural setting, with old stone stables and vineyard views, it's La Bell'antiglia. If you're after a spa, sauna and a large centuries-old garden, Il Poggio Di Teo has the edge, with a higher amenities score (7.4 versus 6.9) and equally good reviews.