Top 8: Villas avec petit-déjeuner en Maremme

Tosco Villa Preselle comes out ahead of the Note Toscana Cachée, 7.8 to 7.4, thanks to a countryside setting and a stronger integration into the hills, and its traveler rating of 9.4 out of 478 reviews places it among the best rated. It suits those who want a quiet rural stay and are ready to pay €391 a night. B&B Villa Clodia, at €248, will appeal to those looking for good value for money near the Saturnia thermal baths, with a tighter budget.

Tosco On price, Villa Preselle is €391 a night versus €638 for Villa Domizia, and its Hidden Tuscany Score (7.8 vs 7.1) as well as its blend into the landscape (8.1 vs 6.2) put it ahead. Villa Domizia, for its part, has the advantage of air conditioning, a seaside location and direct sea access, so it suits those who want the beach and a more complete level of comfort. For a countryside stay with a pool and breakfast on a smaller budget, go for Preselle; for the sea, and if the budget allows, Domizia.

Tosco Villa Preselle Country Resort (7.8) outperforms Villa Porta A Colle (7.0) on almost every criterion, at €391 versus €485 a night. Choose it if you want a historic 19th-century villa in the middle of olive groves, with a pool, breakfast and restaurant included, and very high guest reviews (9.4/10 from 478 reviews). Villa Porta A Colle, for its part, has air conditioning and a fitness room, but its 59 reviews and higher rate make it less convincing.

Tosco On the Hidden Tuscany Score, Villa Preselle clearly wins (7.8 vs 6.9), thanks to its 19th-century historic setting in the heart of the olive groves and its €391 a night for a pool, breakfast and restaurant, even though air conditioning isn't specified. Il Mulino In Maremma appeals with its amenities, air conditioning included, for 5 people, but its price and architectural character are not documented and its guest rating rests on only 10 reviews. Choose Preselle if you want a pool and a villa with character, Il Mulino if air conditioning and space matter most.

Tosco Price makes the difference: Villa Porta A Colle costs €485 a night versus €638 for Hotel Villa Domizia, and its guest rating is better (8.4/10 from 59 reviews, versus 9.4/10 from 0 reviews, so no real value). If you want the sea, the pool and an address on the seafront in Santa Liberata, Hotel Villa Domizia wins on location (7.8 versus 7.2), but the low reliability score calls for caution. For a quiet escape in the countryside near Vetulonia, with pool and fitness room, Villa Porta A Colle is the safest choice.

Tosco B&B Villa Clodia takes the lead on the Hidden Tuscany Score with 7.4 versus 6.9, thanks to its historic building (8.3) built on a former travertine quarry and a pool, ideal if you want a stay in Saturnia with real character. Il Mulino In Maremma, in Farnese, is better suited to a group of 5 that cares first about air conditioning, the kitchenette and the washing machine, and it is rated higher by guests (8.8/10), but its price is not specified.