Wines of Carmignano & Prato, compared head to head

Tosco The score speaks almost for itself: the Poggilarca Carmignano DOCG (Magnum) reaches 7.4 with a value-for-money rating of 7.4, while the Riserva Grumarello tops out at 7.3. For a festive table, the Artimino magnum stands out, with its 85% Sangiovese and 15% Cabernet Franc, 12 months of oak aging and a price brought down to €18.12 per 75 cl, not to mention its versatility highlighted for roast poultry. The Riserva, at €32, will appeal to lovers of roasted red meats, game and aged cheeses thanks to its 24 months in oak and serving temperature of 16-18 °C, but its Cabernet Sauvignon grape makes it more classic. Their differences are slim, each excellent on typicity and the absence of distinctions, so choose according to format and pairing.

Tosco The Poggilarca Carmignano DOCG (Magnum) from Artimino, at €36 a bottle, offers you the best value for money with €18.12 per liter for a blend of 85% Sangiovese and 15% Cabernet Franc, while the Carmignano Riserva DOCG, at €53, rises to €26.68 per 75 cl for longer aging of 24 months and more enveloping tannins. The Riserva, with its pairings with game and aged cheeses, is for you if you're hosting a hearty meal for several people, whereas the first, lighter and more versatile for roast poultry, suits a tight budget better. In terms of quality, their scores are nearly tied (7.4 vs. 7.3) and neither shows any distinction, but the price and the aging give you the real key to choosing.

Tosco The two Carmignano Riserva DOCG wines from Artimino earn the same rating (7.3) and share blend, aging and the absence of any award, but the price gap is clear: €53 for the large 1.5 L format of version A (about €26.68 per 75 cl), versus €32 for bottle B alone. So you choose the magnum format if you're hosting more than six guests or want a grand gesture at the table, and the classic bottle if you're dining alone or as a couple, for a gentler price. Version A comes with more detailed vinification notes and pairings (serving temperature 18–20 °C), while B is more complete about the producer; to avoid a wrong pick, go for the large format for a celebration, the single bottle for tasting.

Tosco The score is identical, 7.3, but the real difference comes down to your wallet and your taste. The Carmignano DOCG at €18 is the smart choice for a simple table of red meats or cheeses, with 12 to 18 months of aging that remains accessible. For €32, the Riserva Grumarello appeals to those who want the more accomplished version, with its 24 months in wood and 6 months in bottle, and a more precise blend of 80% Sangiovese. If you're looking for an everyday wine, take the first; if it's for a special occasion or a curious enthusiast, the Riserva justifies its higher price.

Tosco The Toscana Nascosta score for the Poggilarca is 7.4, that of the Carmignano from Tenuta di Artimino 7.3: a slim gap, but the criteria help you decide. At €18 for the classic bottle, you'd favor the Carmignano – Tenuta di Artimino for a low-cost discovery of the estate, with its versatility at the table rated 7.8; at €36, the Poggilarca in magnum is more for the knowledgeable enthusiast, drawn to its detailed winemaking (8.2) and generous format for a meal with several people. Both suffer from a lack of documented recognition, so if your budget is tight and your wish is simple, choose the second; if you're after the 85% Sangiovese blend and a grand gesture, the first.