AIl Vecchio Mulino
Montalcino · €€ · Mid-range
reliability medium
≈ 25 € / pers.
9,0/10 travellers · 105 reviews
BTrattoria Il Nibbio
Manciano · €€ · Moderate
reliability high
≈ 25 € / pers.
8,3/10 travellers · 86 reviews
The verdict
Il Vecchio Mulino takes the lead
Il Vecchio Mulino scores 7,1/10, ahead of Trattoria Il Nibbio (6,7). In Montalcino, this pizzeria offers pizzas at €7 to €15, five Montalcino DOC pizzas and Chianina IGP della Val di Chiana, for about €25 per person. The menu remains dominated by pizza, with few Tuscan dishes beyond antipasti.
Choose Il Vecchio Mulino if…
- you want the safest value in the duel: best overall score (7,1), level with or ahead on rapport qualité/prix
- your budget matters: from €25 / pers., the lowest price in the head-to-head
- you trust travellers: 9,0/10 from 105 reviews, the best rating in the head-to-head
Its weak point in this head-to-head: typicité locale (7,1). Five Montalcino DOC pizzas and Chianina IGP della Val di Chiana anchor the menu, but the whole remains dominated by classic pizzas.
Choose Trattoria Il Nibbio if…
- you prioritise typicité locale (8,3 vs 7,1) : Menu shaped by Maremma: cinghiale alla maremmana, trippa alla montemeranese, pici, pappa al pomodoro, pecorino toscano, bresaola di cinghiale.
- your budget matters: from €25 / pers., the lowest price in the head-to-head
Reliability medium / high : ratings based on the file of each listing and 86 to 105 traveller reviews, not on a stay by our team · Ratings of the 20 October 2026 · Our rating method
Criterion by criterion
The 5 criteria of the score
Why these ratings?
Il Vecchio MulinoTraveler rating 9.2/10 from 105 reviews: within the top 48% of the catalog.
Il NibbioTraveler rating 8.8/10 from 86 reviews: behind 66% of the catalog.
Why these ratings?
Il Vecchio MulinoTraveler rating 8.9/10 from 105 reviews: behind 61% of the catalog.
Il NibbioTraveler rating 7.8/10 from 86 reviews: behind 96% of the catalog.
Why these ratings?
Il Vecchio MulinoTraveler rating 8.6/10 from 105 reviews: behind 70% of the catalog.
Il NibbioTraveler rating 7.8/10 from 86 reviews: behind 92% of the catalog.
Why these ratings?
Il Vecchio MulinoPizzas at €7 to €15 and desserts at €6 to €8, for an average of €25 per person: consistent, with a named Chianina IGP, but supplements of €1 to €2.
Il NibbioAverage price of €25 for primi between €13 and €16 and pizzas from €7 to €10, pappardelle with wild boar at €14: gentle prices for home cooking.
Why these ratings?
Il Vecchio MulinoFive Montalcino DOC pizzas and Chianina IGP della Val di Chiana anchor the menu, but the whole remains dominated by classic pizzas.
Il NibbioMenu shaped by Maremma: cinghiale alla maremmana, trippa alla montemeranese, pici, pappa al pomodoro, pecorino toscano, bresaola di cinghiale.
Features
Price, village, amenities
What is written on the listing. “Not specified” is not “no”.
| Criterion | Il Vecchio Mulino | Il Nibbio |
|---|---|---|
| Recorded price | ≈ 25 € / pers. | ≈ 25 € / pers. |
| Village | Montalcino | Manciano |
| Traveller rating | 9,0/10 · 105 reviews | 8,3/10 · 86 reviews |
| Reliability of our score | medium | high |
| Cuisine | Pizzeria | Italian cuisine |
| Price | €€ · Mid-range | €€ · Mid-range |
TheForkIf you book or order through one of these links, we earn a commission, at no extra cost to you. The partner never influences the rating or the verdict.
Change an address
Other well-rated restaurants
Other duels
Also worth reading
vs
Restaurants · Montalcino
Enoteca Svanen or Il Passaggio by Capanna?
The two best-rated restaurants: Montalcino
vs
Restaurants · Montalcino
Enoteca Svanen or Pura Crocus?
Two well-rated restaurants: Montalcino
vs
Restaurants · Montalcino
Il Passaggio by Capanna or Castello Banfi - Sala dei Grappoli?
Two budgets: €50 vs. €76