AIl Caro Commendatore
Montefiascone · €€ · Medium
reliability high
≈ 35 € / pers.
9,4/10 travellers · 2769 reviews
BLa Perla Fattoria Pianetti
Manciano · €€ · Moderate
reliability high
≈ 33 € / pers.
9,3/10 travellers · 377 reviews
The verdict
Il Caro Commendatore and La Perla Fattoria Pianetti neck and neck
8,4 versus 8,2: the gap is too small to separate them on the overall rating. The choice comes down to the criteria that matter to you, below.
Choose Il Caro Commendatore if…
- you trust travellers: 9,4/10 from 2769 reviews, the best rating in the head-to-head
Its weak point in this head-to-head: typicité locale (7,3). Regional meat menu: tortelli del commendatore, filetto di porcocignale, coniglio della commenda, strozzapreti, spezzatino; house wines.
Choose La Perla Fattoria Pianetti if…
- you prioritise typicité locale (8,6 vs 7,3) : Very Maremman menu: acquacotta, pici all'aglione, cinghiale, cacciucco, pecorino, Morellino, chianina IGP; rare touches from outside the region (teriyaki).
- your budget matters: from €33 / pers., the lowest price in the head-to-head
Reliability high : ratings based on the file of each listing and 377 to 2769 traveller reviews, not on a stay by our team · Ratings of the 20 October 2026 · Our rating method
Tosco's word
Il Caro Commendatore takes the lead on the Note Toscane Cachée (8.4 vs. 8.2) and on both cuisine and service, where it earns 9.2 each; it will suit those who want a very polished table at €35 per person, regional meat menu included. La Perla Fattoria Pianetti, at €33, appeals mainly for its setting (9.0) and its Maremman typicity (8.6), but the meat sold by weight can quickly climb, so it's best to check prices before ordering.
Tosco only cites facts from this head-to-head: ratings, criteria, prices, amenities. Text calculated once, checked by the code.
Criterion by criterion
The 5 criteria of the score
Why these ratings?
Il Caro CommendatoreTraveler rating 9.5/10 based on 2769 reviews: among the top 6% of the catalogue.
La Perla Fattoria PianettiGuest rating 9.3/10 from 377 reviews: among the top 27% of the catalog.
Why these ratings?
Il Caro CommendatoreTraveler rating 9.5/10 based on 2769 reviews: among the top 6% of the catalogue.
La Perla Fattoria PianettiGuest rating 9.1/10 from 377 reviews: among the top 40% of the catalog.
Why these ratings?
Il Caro CommendatoreTraveler rating 9.2/10 based on 2769 reviews: among the top 22% of the catalogue.
La Perla Fattoria PianettiGuest rating 9.5/10 from 377 reviews: among the top 11% of the catalog.
Why these ratings?
Il Caro CommendatoreAt €35 per person, mains (€18-28), pasta (€18-20) and wines from €4 form a consistent house menu, with no budget pricing.
La Perla Fattoria PianettiAverage price €33 for dishes at €14-24, homemade pasta and soups, but meat sold by weight rises to €55-130/kg: a coherent menu, though not gentle.
Why these ratings?
Il Caro CommendatoreRegional meat menu: tortelli del commendatore, filetto di porcocignale, coniglio della commenda, strozzapreti, spezzatino; house wines.
La Perla Fattoria PianettiVery Maremman menu: acquacotta, pici all'aglione, cinghiale, cacciucco, pecorino, Morellino, chianina IGP; rare touches from outside the region (teriyaki).
Features
Price, village, amenities
What is written on the listing. “Not specified” is not “no”.
| Criterion | Il Caro Commendatore | La Perla Fattoria Pianetti |
|---|---|---|
| Recorded price | ≈ 35 € / pers. | ≈ 33 € / pers. |
| Village | Montefiascone | Manciano |
| Traveller rating | 9,4/10 · 2769 reviews | 9,3/10 · 377 reviews |
| Reliability of our score | high | high |
| Cuisine | Meat & grill | Meat & grill |
| Price | €€ · Mid-range | €€ · Mid-range |
TheForkIf you book or order through one of these links, we earn a commission, at no extra cost to you. The partner never influences the rating or the verdict.
Other duels
The other head-to-heads: Restaurants en Maremme : Viande & grill
vs
Restaurants · Meat & grill
Il Cerchio delle Streghe Country House or Capanna del Buttero?
The top two in the ranking: Meat & grill
vsRestaurants · Meat & grill
Capanna del Buttero or Il Caro Commendatore?
#2 vs #3 in the ranking: Meat & grill
vsRestaurants · Meat & grill
Il Cerchio delle Streghe Country House or Il Caro Commendatore?
#1 vs #3 in the ranking: Meat & grill