Top 20: Hôtels avec vue sur les collines à Pitigliano

Tosco Santa Monaca holds the highest Toscane Cachée score (7.8 versus 7.5), thanks to a well-integrated 15th-century building (8.7) and a location one minute from the Fortezza Orsini, but its €270 per night weighs heavily (value for money at 6.6). If your budget is comfortable and you care about the medieval character, it's the one; if you're traveling with several people and want two bedrooms and a equipped kitchen without paying a lot, Antica Porta di Sovana, 350 m from the center, is the most reasonable choice, even though its price isn't listed.

Tosco Santa Monaca beats Toscane Cachée's score (7.8 versus 7.5), thanks to better-rated integration of the old building (8.7) and more complete facilities: air conditioning, an equipped kitchen and parking. It is also a 1-minute walk from the Fortezza Orsini, for €270 per night. Casa Messi, at €231, suits those who want to sleep in the heart of the historic center on a tighter budget, but it offers fewer amenities, with no air conditioning mentioned, and its high guest rating (8.9 out of 10 from 338 reviews) doesn't make up for everything.

Tosco Antica Porta di Sovana (rating 7.5, 8.8/10 from 91 reviews) appeals to those who want two bedrooms, an equipped kitchen and parking nearby, 350 m from the center, though without a listed price it's hard to decide. Casa Messi (rating 7.5, 8.9/10 from 338 reviews) suits those who prefer the heart of the historic center and the 15th-century building, but at €231 per night for a studio with limited facilities, value for money remains low. For a small budget and the desire to cook together, Antica Porta di Sovana takes the lead.

Tosco Antica Porta di Sovana takes the lead over the Note Toscane Cachée (7.5 vs. 7.4) and on location (8.2 vs. 7.6), 350 m from the historic center of Pitigliano with nearby parking, ideal if you're traveling by car and want two bedrooms. Il Carisma, at €220 a night, appeals more to those who want the heart of the village on foot, breakfast, and old stone walls (8.2 for integration), but its value for money (6.1) weighs heavily.

Tosco Santa Monaca comes out ahead of the Note Toscane Cachée (7.8 vs. 7.4), especially for location (8.1 vs. 7.6): the Fortezza Orsini is a 1-minute walk away, with air conditioning, parking, and a equipped kitchen, but at €270 a night. Il Carisma, at €220, is better suited to a small group of 4 who want breakfast included, without A/C or parking, in an apartment in the heart of the old town.

Tosco On price, Il Carisma (€220) is slightly cheaper than Casa Messi (€231), and it includes breakfast and an apartment for 4 people, which makes it more relevant for a small group. Casa Messi, with its Note Toscane Cachée of 7.5 vs. 7.4 and its location in the center a few steps from the Palazzo Orsini Museum, is better for those who want hill views and a 15th-century building, but with no breakfast mentioned.