Hotels and B&Bs in Scansano, compared head to head

Tosco The guest rating of Morelliana 4 Rooms (9.3 across 331 reviews) clearly exceeds that of Antico Casale Di Scansano Resort (8.8 across 451), and its price of €128 versus €181 leaves room for breakfast, which is extra. If you want to sleep in the heart of Scansano, 90 m from the village, with your dog, and prefer a small property of four rooms, choose Morelliana. Antico Casale, for its part, will appeal to you if you're looking for a 19th-century farmhouse with a pool, spa and views of the hills, even if it means being 1.5 km from the center and paying more for these amenities.

Tosco The Toscane Cachée score of Morelliana 4 Rooms (7.7) edges out that of Casa Romantica Pereta (7.5), but comfort is what really decides it: Casa Romantica, with its two separate bedrooms, equipped kitchen, air conditioning and fireplace, suits a family or those who want to cook, while Morelliana, more central in Scansano and cheaper (€128 versus €145), appeals to couples who prefer the restaurant and bar without moving. For you, looking for the independence and calm of Pereta, choose Casa Romantica; for a practical base within walking distance, with paid breakfast on top, Morelliana remains a good option, even though its rooms are poorly described.

Tosco The value-for-money balance tips toward Casa Romantica Pereta: at €145, you get two separate bedrooms, a equipped kitchen, air conditioning and a comfort score of 8.1, compared with €181 for Antico Casale Di Scansano Resort, which banks on its spa, pool and 19th-century farmhouse setting, with a solid guest rating of 8.8 across 451 reviews. If you're looking for independence and the calm of a medieval village in Pereta, with a church 6 minutes away on foot, Casa Romantica is made for you, especially for two people or a small group. On the other hand, for a complete 4-star experience with restaurant, free parking and views of the hills, without worrying about details, Antico Casale stands out, even though its 7.6 and its 7.3 for comfort remain below Casa Romantica's; the gaps are slim, but your priorities decide.

Tosco The value-for-money score of Antico Casale Di Scansano Resort, rated 7.2 versus 6.6 for Sasseta Alta, is the first gap that matters: at €181 versus €208, you gain a spa, free parking and a higher comfort score (7.3 versus 7.1), even though air conditioning remains unclear. Sasseta Alta appeals with its organic stone agriturismo, included breakfast and pets allowed, with a slightly better guest rating (8.9 across 186 reviews), but its higher price for less detailed amenities reserves it for those who value rustic charm and the company of their dog. For a comfortable stay with complete services, choose the resort; for an authentic farm atmosphere with your animal, opt for Sasseta Alta, accepting a tighter budget.

Tosco At €236, Relax in Maremma tra Saturnia e Argentario offers you complete comfort (spa, air conditioning, two bedrooms over 45 m²) but its integration into the landscape remains vague, while Sasseta Alta, at €208, banks on the charm of stone casali and a pool, with a slightly higher guest rating (8.9 versus 8.8) and a location closer to the thermal baths. If you prioritize detailed amenities and the restaurant, choose the first; for an authentic setting and hills as far as the eye can see, the second will win you over. The gaps are slim, but your budget and your desire for a spa or pool will make the difference.