Go to content
Hidden Tuscany

Duels · Wine tastings · Montalcino

Top 30: Dégustations de vin à Montalcino

46 tastings rated for Montalcino, average rating 7,0. The 30 best-rated range from 6,8 to 8,1. Leading: Montalcino : Visite guidée des vignobles et dégustation de vins (8,1), Dégustation de vin classique à Sanlorenzo à Montalcino (8,0) et Casato Prime Donne (7,6). Only one listing in the ranking mentions “en couple”: Dégustation de vin et visite de la cave à Poggio Dell'Aquila.

46rated addresses
7,0average rating
—top 30, / pers.
6duels to read
Share

The ranking

Top 30: Montalcino

Ranked by the editorial score. The head-to-heads below pit the leaders against each other.

#PlaceRatingEstate20 %Wines tasted25 %Home15 %Value20 %Guest reviews20 %TravellersPrice
1Montalcino: Guided tour of the vineyards and wine tastingMid-range8,18,27,77,38,19,09,8 · 219—
2Classic wine tasting at Sanlorenzo in MontalcinoMid-range8,08,38,76,97,6———
3Casato Prime DonneMid-range7,68,67,36,96,78,29,6 · 240—
4Vintage tasting at Musico's cellar in MontalcinoUpscale7,68,67,97,26,6———
5Storica: Heritage Brunello Tasting at the Caprili winery in MontalcinoUpscale7,68,68,27,26,2———
6Guided tour of the cellar and tasting of gourmet products at Tenuta Corte Pavone in MontalcinoMid-range7,68,27,67,27,2———
7CamiglianoEconomical7,57,97,26,87,18,69,8 · 150—
8Guided tour of the cellar and wine tasting at the Tenuta Corte Pavone in MontalcinoEconomical7,57,67,47,27,9———
9Wine tasting and cellar tour at Poggio Dell'AquilaMid-range7,48,46,67,97,2———
10Vertical wine tasting and cellar tour at Caprili in MontalcinoMid-range7,48,67,47,26,3———
11Tenute Silvio NardiMid-range7,48,47,46,17,27,89,4 · 120—
12A taste of Casanuova delle Cerbaie in MontalcinoMid-range7,38,37,37,26,37,49,8 · 8—
13Cellar tour and vertical Brunello tasting in Montalcino at Tenuta Corte PavoneEconomical7,37,87,66,66,9———
14Winery tour and Brunello Vertical gastronomic tasting at Tenuta Corte Pavone in MontalcinoEconomical7,37,27,36,87,8———
15Brunello wine experience at Sanlorenzo in MontalcinoUpscale7,37,47,66,97,17,410,0 · 8—
16Classic wine tasting and cellar tour at Caprili in MontalcinoMid-range7,28,56,97,16,2———
17Brunello tasting and typical products at Corte dei Venti in MontalcinoMid-range7,18,66,46,17,1———
18Terroir tasting at the Villa le Prata cellar in MontalcinoUpscale7,17,88,26,96,45,710,0 · 1—
19Superior quality wine tasting at Casanuova delle Cerbaie in MontalcinoMid-range7,17,97,65,96,27,39,8 · 7—
20Wine and food tour in Tuscany at the Poggio Stenti wineryMid-range7,17,37,17,17,66,510,0 · 2—
21Casanuova delle Cerbaie Wine Education Experience in Montalcino (in English only)Mid-range7,07,27,17,26,7———
22Behind the scenes of Brunello with wine and food tasting at Tenuta Corte Pavone in MontalcinoUpscale7,07,27,86,36,2———
23Friendly tasting at Villa Le Prata in MontalcinoEconomical7,07,67,46,17,36,510,0 · 2—
24Gold wine tasting at the Musico cellar in MontalcinoUpscale7,07,47,26,07,1———
25Emotional experience at La Togata in MontalcinoMid-range7,08,37,26,16,2———
26"Classic" wine tasting at Sesta di SopraMid-range6,98,16,67,36,95,79,0 · 2—
27Purple Morning - Brunello & Rosso Wine Tasting at the Giodo cellarMid-range6,98,66,66,16,3———
28Tour and tasting in Brunello country at Tenuta Pian delle GinestreMid-range6,98,76,96,07,25,710,0 · 1—
29Wine and food tasting at the Tenuta Corte Pavone in MontalcinoEconomical6,86,87,66,17,85,18,0 · 1—
30Vertical Brunello tasting at Sesta di Sopra in MontalcinoMid-range6,87,37,46,16,2———

Hidden Tuscany Rating · rank in the “Wine tastings” family · our method · All tastings · Montalcino in the hub →

Duels to read

The comparisons that matter: Montalcino

Pairs picked by the code from the best-rated ones; Tosco's word is calculated once, from the same facts.

vs

Montalcino: Guided tour of the vineyards and wine tasting or Classic wine tasting at Sanlorenzo in Montalcino?

Les deux premiers du classement : Montalcino · 8,1 vs 8,0

8,18,0Read the duel →
vs

Montalcino: Guided tour of the vineyards and wine tasting or Casato Prime Donne?

N°1 contre N°3 du classement : Montalcino · 8,1 vs 7,6

Tosco The gap widens on content: Corte Pavone offers you two hours, six wines and a meal for an average price, whereas Casato Prime Donne gives you one hour, three identified wines (including the Brunello Riserva) and cheeses. If you want a complete, biodynamic experience with an expert guide, choose Montalcino: Guided vineyard tour; for a quick, clear family discovery of Brunello, Casato Prime Donne suits you. Traveler ratings lean toward the first (9.8 out of 219 reviews versus 9.6 out of 240), but the difference is slight: it all depends on your time and your appetite.

8,17,6Read the duel →
vs

Montalcino: Guided tour of the vineyards and wine tasting or Vintage tasting at the Musico cellar in Montalcino?

N°1 contre N°4 du classement : Montalcino · 8,1 vs 7,6

8,17,6Read the duel →
vs

Montalcino: Guided tour of the vineyards and wine tasting or Storica: Brunello Heritage tasting at the Caprili cellar in Montalcino?

N°1 contre N°5 du classement : Montalcino · 8,1 vs 7,6

8,17,6Read the duel →
vs

Classic wine tasting at Sanlorenzo in Montalcino or Casato Prime Donne?

N°2 contre N°3 du classement : Montalcino · 8,0 vs 7,6

8,07,6Read the duel →
vs

Classic wine tasting at Sanlorenzo in Montalcino or Vintage tasting at the Musico cellar in Montalcino?

N°2 contre N°4 du classement : Montalcino · 8,0 vs 7,6

8,07,6Read the duel →

My advice: Montalcino

If you're looking for the best balance between content and price, the Montalcino: Guided vineyard tour and wine tasting stands out with its score of 8.1, six wines and a meal at a mid-range price, whereas the Classic wine tasting at Sanlorenzo in Montalcino shines for the precision of its references (five named wines) but suffers from low reliability. The Vintage tasting at the Musico cellar and the Storica at Caprili are tempting for their rare Brunellos, but their unspecified high-end pricing and low reliability make them better suited to enthusiasts willing to pay without guarantees. The catch is the systematic absence of an exact price and of an actual language of service, so favor reliable mid-range options like Casato Prime Donne if you want a short hour with cheeses, and keep Musico for a special occasion in Montalcino.

Tosco only cites facts on this page: names, ratings, prices, amenities. Text calculated once, checked by the code.

Alcohol abuse is dangerous for health, consume in moderation.

All tastings
Agriturismo Activities Sleep Eat Plan Car