Top 10: Villas à Pitigliano

Tosco Villa Collina scores 7.2 on the Note Toscane Cachée against 7.1 for Villa Ermida, a minimal gap, but price decides it: €810 a night for Collina, while Ermida's rate isn't specified. Collina suits large groups who want 7 bedrooms, 6 bathrooms and a 5x12 m pool in Pitigliano, with a committed budget. Ermida, smaller and rural, appeals to those who prioritize blending into the landscape, provided you check the price.

Tosco For a large group looking for comfort and a 5x12 m pool, Villa Collina wins with its Note Toscane Cachée of 7.2 against 7.0, its complete amenities and 7 bedrooms, even at €810 a night. The Villa in Pitigliano, built in stone and more integrated into the landscape (7.3 against 6.1), will appeal to those who want local character, but since its price isn't specified and its reliability is low, it needs checking before you commit.

Tosco Villa Ermida In Sorano takes the lead for large groups: 14 people, 5 bedrooms, private pool and hot tub, with comfort rated 7.6 against 7.2 for the Villa in Pitigliano. The latter, more modest for 9 people with a pool and fenced garden, suits smaller groups who want a stone house well integrated into the landscape. The two overall scores remain close (7.1 and 7.0), and the missing prices leave the budget question open.

Tosco Villa Collina scores 7.2 against 6.9 for Elegant Villa with Spa in Sorano, but the gap is mainly about price: €810 a night for 7 bedrooms, 6 bathrooms and 10,000 m² of garden, which makes sense for a large group. Elegant Villa suits six people who want a full spa and an on-site restaurant, but since its rate isn't specified, there's no way to know whether the offer is worth it. Without a price, I can't separate them seriously: ask for the rate before deciding.

Tosco Villa Collina has a private pool and the capacity for a large group, with €810 a night for 7 bedrooms and 10,000 m² of garden, but its score of 7.2 remains average and its air conditioning isn't specified. Il Mulino In Maremma, in Farnese, offers more comfort for 5 people with air conditioning, a kitchenette and a restaurant, but its price isn't listed and its reliability is low. For a large group that wants a pool, Villa Collina; for a small group that insists on A/C, Il Mulino.

Tosco Villa Ermida In Sorano comes out ahead on the Note Toscane Cachée (7.1 against 6.9), largely thanks to its integration into the landscape (7.3 against 5.9): it is a rural casale in the hills near Elmo, ideal for a group of 14 people with a private pool and hot tub. Elegant Villa with Spa in Sorano suits six people better if they want a full spa (sauna, Turkish bath, hot tub) and an on-site restaurant, but its architectural character remains unclear. With no prices listed, value for money doesn't settle it.