Top 10: Hôtels de 200 à 400 €/nuit à Massa Marittima

Tosco Palazzo Malfatti wins on location (8.4) and integration into the heritage (8.8): a 13th-century palace in the heart of town, a stone's throw from Piazza Garibaldi, for those who want to do everything on foot. Panorama-Ferien-Toscana, at €227 vs. €281, is better suited to those who drive and want a private terrace, quiet and free parking, with the best traveler rating (9.4/10 from 70 reviews).

Tosco Panorama-Ferien-Toscana beats the Note Toscane Cachée, 7.5 to 7.4, with better-documented comfort (private terrace, free parking, apartments of about 50 m²) and a slightly better value for money at €227 a night. Choose it if you're traveling as a family or with four people and want space and quiet, 2.1 km from the center by car. Al 32 B&B suits those who want to do everything on foot from the Duomo, with breakfast included, but at €238 with no parking or pool, it's expensive for what it offers.

Tosco Palazzo Malfatti earns the best Note Toscane Cachée (7.6 vs. 7.4) thanks to its heritage character (8.8 vs. 6.8) and apartments with a kitchen and private entrance, ideal for a group stay or a longer visit. Al 32 B&B, at €238 a night versus €281, will appeal more to travellers who want breakfast included and a guest rating of 9.6/10 across 159 reviews.

Tosco Palazzo Malfatti wins the Note Toscane Cachée (7.6 to 7.4) thanks to a more distinctive heritage (8.8 to 7.2) and more complete facilities including air conditioning, for €281 a night versus €362. Choose it if you want a renovated apartment in a 13th-century palace, a stone's throw from Piazza Garibaldi, and you don't mind paying without breakfast or parking. Carmelita, 100 m from Piazza del Duomo, is aimed more at groups: 60 m² for five people, two balconies, free street parking, and a guest rating of 9.4/10 from 38 reviews.

Tosco Al 32 B&B starts with a Note Toscane Cachée of 7.4 and a location a few steps from the Duomo, but its value for money rates only 5.9 at €238 a night, with breakfast, Wi-Fi and air conditioning only. Carmelita has the same 7.4 score for a 60 m² apartment 100 m from Piazza del Duomo, with a equipped kitchen, two balconies and free parking, but at €362 a night. For a couple or a small group who want good value on a short stay, Al 32 B&B is the most sensible choice; for five people who want to cook and enjoy private space, Carmelita has the edge.

Tosco Panorama-Ferien-Toscana costs €227 a night versus €362 for Carmelita, and offers air conditioning, Wi-Fi, free parking and a private terrace, with a score of 7.5 versus 7.4. If you want hill views and quiet 2.1 km from the center by car, go with Panorama-Ferien-Toscana. If you insist on sleeping 100 m from Piazza del Duomo without needing a car, Carmelita holds its own, but you pay considerably more for fewer amenities.